Commercial Insurance Coverage in an Evolving Threat Environment

Summary

The proliferation of natural catastrophe threats has raised concerns about commercial insurance coverage for real estate. These concerns have highlighted the lack of—and need for—insurance capacity and various lines of commercial insurance. Risks from natural disasters like floods, hurricanes, wildfires, hail, tornadoes, and drought cost the U.S. billions of dollars each year. Even if policyholders are able to find coverage for these various lines, prices are increasing dramatically. A lack of adequate coverage will lead to economic uncertainty, harm stakeholders, and undermine the growth of communities.

While commercial property rates are finally stabilizing or even decreasing for high-quality risks, casualty and liability lines continue to face significant upward pressure. Average rates are trending downward by 4.6 percent, with some well-maintained portfolios seeing decreases of 10 percent to 20 percent. A dominant driver for liability lines includes jury awards exceeding $10 million, which have increased by over 300 percent since 2020--particularly affecting the hospitality and real estate sectors.

Spending legislation passed this year has reauthorized the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) through Sept. 30, 2026.

RER, along with its industry partners, continues to work constructively with policymakers and stakeholders to address market failure and enact a long-term reauthorization of an improved NFIP.

Key Takeaways

After years of atypical weather patterns and historic losses from natural catastrophes attributed to climate change, economic damages have tripled in cost from just 10 years ago.

Severe storms have surpassed hurricanes as the costliest insured weather peril.

Properties previously considered low-risk are now being re-evaluated due to changes in drainage pressure and local infrastructure.

Due to cumulative construction inflation (up nearly 40 percent since 2020), many properties are currently insured below their actual replacement value.

Commercial property owners continue to take steps to mitigate the risk of natural disasters and potentially lower their insurance costs.

See the full fact sheet.

Position

Enact a Long-Term Reauthorization of NFIP: The level of flood damage from recent storms makes it clear that FEMA needs a holistic plan to prepare the nation for managing the cost of catastrophic flooding under the NFIP.

  • RER and its partners support a long-term reauthorization of an improved NFIP that helps property owners and renters prepare for and recover from future flood losses. NFIP is essential for residential markets, overall natural catastrophe insurance market capacity, and the broader economy.

Increase Private Market Participation: By permitting certain private issue insurance policies to satisfy the NFIP’s “mandatory purchase requirement” for properties in flood plains financed by loans from federally guaranteed institutions, commercial property owners would have the ability to “opt out” of mandatory NFIP commercial coverage if they have adequate private coverage outside the NFIP to cover financed assets.

  • Lenders typically require base NFIP coverage, and commercial owners must purchase Supplemental Excess Flood Insurance for coverage above the NFIP limits. The NFIP’s low commercial limits make it problematic for most commercial owners.
  • As a result, RER has been seeking a voluntary exemption for mandatory NFIP coverage if property owners have flood coverage from commercial insurers.
Background

National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP)

  •  Floods are the most common, costliest natural peril in the U.S. The NFIP was enacted in 1968 due to a lack of private insurance and increases in federal disaster aid.
  • The Program is administered by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and is essential for homeowners, renters, and small businesses in affected areas.
  • Under the NFIP, commercial property flood insurance limits are low—$500,000 per building and $500,000 for its contents. NFIP has approximately 5 million total properties, and only 6.7 percent are commercial. Nearly 70 percent of NFIP is devoted to single-family homes and 20 percent to condominiums. In the total program, 80 percent pay actuarial sound rates; however, in the commercial space, only 60 percent pay actuarial sound rates.
  • NFIP faces long-standing solvency and flood mapping challenges that require structural reform. The unintended negative outcomes generated by the NFIP continue to grow and are now spreading to GSEs (government-sponsored enterprises) Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
  • Since 2017, Congress has extended the NFIP’s authorization 35 times.
  • As policymakers continue to debate potential changes and improvements to the program, their challenge is to find a balance between improving the financial solvency of the program, reducing taxpayer exposure, and addressing affordability concerns.
MORE ISSUES
MORE ISSUES
Reauthorizing Federal Terrorism Insurance
Addressing the Wave of Maturing CRE Debt and Pro-Cyclical Regulatory Policy
Commercial Insurance Coverage in an Evolving Threat Environment
Beneficial Ownership & the Corporate Transparency Act
"Safeguarding Rule" Withdrawal
Gold and Platinum “Trump Cards” and the EB-5 Visa
Democratizing Access to Alternative Assets for 401(k) Investors