Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the Future of Housing Finance in the U.S.
Summary
In response to the Global Financial Crisis in September 2008, the U.S. Treasury placed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac into conservatorship under the oversight of the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA). This action was intended to stabilize the mortgage market and restore confidence in the government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs). It also involved an injection of $190 billion of capital, while creating an explicit U.S. government guarantee. The ongoing conservatorship means that the government has total control over these huge government-backed mortgage enterprises, with $7.7 trillion in combined assets.
Conservatorship was not meant to be indefinite. More than 18 years later, the GSEs are in a much stronger financial position and have repaid the $187 billion used to preserve Fannie and Freddie during the financial crisis. Yet, retiring the government’s preferred and common equity stake would require a refinancing of massive scale, a taxpayer gift from the U.S. Treasury of tens of billions of dollars to Fannie and Freddie, or both.
The GSEs are currently "effectively owned" by the U.S. Treasury, which holds senior preferred stock and warrants for 79.9 percent of their common stock. While they have built significant reserves, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projected that their equity value by early 2027 would still fall short of full recapitalization requirements.
Policymakers have increasingly discussed various reform proposals, including ending the conservatorship, full privatization, hybrid models, and continued government backing with additional safeguards. The administration has set reform as a key priority, yet concrete details have yet to emerge.
As policymakers consider privatization or structural reforms, it is essential to the real estate industry and the broader economy to preserve a well-functioning housing finance system that supports homeownership, expands affordable housing supply, and sustains economic growth.
The enactment of the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act in July 2026 directly impacts GSE operations and capital deployment, moving the goalposts for structural housing finance reform:
- Intertwined Legislative Fate: Because the ROAD to Housing Act leveraged banking system relief and increased Public Welfare Investment caps to unlock private capital, standalone legislative GSE reform has been sidelined. Congress has effectively prioritized using the GSEs as tools for immediate supply creation rather than executing a complex wind-down or restructuring of their charters.
- Multifamily Backstop Role: The law explicitly codifies the GSEs' role as a stable liquidity backstop in the commercial and multifamily mortgage markets.
- FHFA Loan Purchase Caps: In alignment with the Act's goals, the FHFA sharply increased the 2026 multifamily loan purchase caps to a combined $176 billion (a 20.5 percent increase over 2025's $146 billion limit). The FHFA committed to a "liquidity backstop" pledge, promising not to reduce these caps even if the broader market contracts.
Key Takeaways
The tension between the executive branch's administrative ambitions and the legislative reality in Congress shapes the future of both GSE reform and institutional housing rules. While the administration utilizes regulatory agencies to bypass legislative gridlock, congressional opposition and structural legal hurdles create significant friction.
The FHFA and the Treasury Department are quietly exploring an administrative "recapitalization and release" framework. With the GSEs holding $328 billion in combined capital, the administration is evaluating a consent decree that would restructure the Treasury’s senior preferred stock and allow the enterprises to exit conservatorship without a new act of Congress.
A complete, rapid exit from conservatorship is considered unlikely in the immediate term due to the technical complexity of raising enough capital to meet regulatory requirements. Instead, a gradual transition involving partial share offerings is more likely.
A critical future debate is whether the government will provide a "paid-for explicit guarantee" on GSE mortgage-backed securities (MBS). Without this, critics warn mortgage rates could spike due to increased risk for private investors.
However, one key concern for a successful exit is the "explicit guarantee." If the government does not legally guarantee the mortgages post-exit, mortgage rates could rise by 0.2 to 0.8 percentage points ($500 to $2,000 more per year for a typical buyer). An explicit, paid-for guarantee would likely stabilize the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage but would require an act of Congress.
If Fannie and Freddie are transitioned to private ownership, the process must ensure financial stability, avoid market disruptions, and protect access to affordable mortgages.
Reforms to the GSEs should be part of a larger national transformation in housing policy to unleash a wave of new housing construction and fully address the underbuilding gap, including Yes in My Backyard (YIMBY) policies, property conversion incentives and reforms to zoning and permitting rules, Opportunity Zones (OZs), and the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC).
See the full fact sheet.