Senate Advances Bipartisan Permitting Reform Bill

On Nov. 9, the Senate voted 73–25 to begin consideration of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (S. 5653), clearing a key initial procedural hurdle but stopping short of approving the legislation. The bill would overhaul federal permitting for energy and infrastructure projects and modernize transmission planning. (U.S. Senate, Nov. 9)

State of Play

  • Bipartisan sponsors: The bill was introduced Sept. 30 by the leaders of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee (Chair Shelley Moore Capito (R-WV) and Ranking Member Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI)) and the Energy and Natural Resources Committee (Chair Mike Lee (R-UT) and Ranking Member Martin Heinrich (D-NM)). A revised version was released Nov. 7. (Bipartisan Policy Center, Oct. 2)
  • NEPA reforms: The bill would set deadlines for environmental reviews, narrow who can challenge projects in court, and limit the time to file challenges under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) to 150 days, matching the House-passed SPEED Act. (Bipartisan Policy Center, Oct. 2)
  • Transmission and grid costs: The bill would give the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) backstop authority to site certain interstate transmission lines. It would also require data centers to pay their full share of grid upgrade costs so other customers do not subsidize them. (White & Case, Nov. 11)

What’s Next

  • Senators will consider amendments, addressing concerns including provisions that would relax federal reviews of a project’s impacts on historic properties. Some Democrats who voted to begin debate have indicated they may oppose the final bill depending on the amendments. (Heatmap, Nov. 9)
  • A final Senate vote could come as early as the week of Nov. 16. The House would then need to consider the legislation before the lame-duck session ends.  (White & Case, Nov. 11)
  • President Trump said Nov. 9 that the bill “hasn’t been fully negotiated.” It remains unclear how his comments could affect the legislation’s prospects. (Heatmap, Nov. 9)

The Real Estate Roundtable (RER) continues to support permitting reform to improve energy affordability and meet growing electricity demand. RER has urged Congress to provide certainty for approved projects and eliminate redundant federal reviews that delay affordable, reliable power. (Roundtable Weekly, Oct. 2, 2026)

Ninth Circuit Allows California Scope 1 and 2 Reporting to Proceed, Blocks Scope 3 and Climate Risk Disclosures

On Nov. 9, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that California can enforce certain corporate climate disclosure requirements while blocking others that likely violate the First Amendment. (Foley & Lardner, Nov. 9)

State of Play

  • Scope 1 and 2 reporting: The court allowed California to enforce Senate Bill (SB) 253’s requirement that companies doing business in the state with more than $1 billion in annual revenue disclose emissions from their direct operations (“Scope 1”) and purchased energy (“Scope 2”). The Nov. 10 deadline for initial Scope 1 and 2 reports remained in effect, requiring covered companies to comply while litigation continues. (Foley & Lardner, Nov. 9)
  • Scope 3 reporting: The court found that SB 253’s requirement to report indirect supply chain and value chain emissions (Scope 3), scheduled to begin in 2027, likely violates the First Amendment. The requirement remains on hold while litigation continues. (Ninth Circuit ruling, Nov. 9)
  • Climate-related financial risk reports: The court maintained its freeze on SB 261, which requires companies doing business in California with more than $500 million in annual revenue to report climate-related financial risks. Enforcement remains on hold while litigation continues. (National Law Review, Nov. 9)

What’s Next

  • The case returns to the district court, which will determine, among other issues, whether the Scope 3 provisions can be separated from the rest of SB 253. Covered companies, including commercial real estate firms, remain subject to Scope 1 and 2 reporting requirements. (Cooley, Nov. 10)

The Real Estate Roundtable (RER) continues to advocate for practical, consistent climate disclosure requirements that limit compliance burdens for commercial real estate owners and operators. RER has raised concerns about mandatory Scope 3 reporting, particularly the challenges of obtaining reliable emissions data from tenants and other third parties, and has urged policymakers to avoid costly, overlapping reporting requirements. (Roundtable Weekly, Nov. 21, 2025)

RER and Broad Coalition Urge Congress to Direct ENERGY STAR Funding to DOE

The Real Estate Roundtable (RER) led a broad coalition of organizations representing real estate, consumer products, manufacturing, retail, technology, and energy efficiency advocates in a letter to congressional appropriators Thursday, urging Congress to provide FY 2027 funding for ENERGY STAR directly to the Department of Energy (DOE) as it assumes leadership of the program from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). (Coalition Letter, Oct. 29)

Coalition Advocacy

  • Federal funding is currently set to expire on December 11. When Congress reconvenes after the midterms, it is expected to consider FY’27 spending legislation through this coming Sept. 30.
  • The coalition urged Congress to continue directed FY’27 appropriations for ENERGY STAR, specifically requesting that program dollars be provided to DOE to align federal funding with the agencies’ new responsibilities.
  • The issue attracts support across the ideological spectrum. In addition to major real estate organizations, signatories range from the American Gas Association and the National Association of Manufacturers, to the U.S. Green Building Council, to the national association representing all state energy offices.
  • The letter emphasized that appropriating funds directly to DOE would strengthen congressional oversight, ensure that expenditures reflect DOE’s lead implementation role, and stabilize the program’s continuity during the transition period.
  • The coalition called for at least $33 million in FY’27 funding, consistent with the amount appropriated last year.  (Bill text (page 85) | Roundtable Weekly, Jan. 9)

ENERGY STAR Transition to DOE

  • In August, DOE and EPA released a transition plan outlining how DOE will assume leadership and core operations of ENERGY STAR, with the transition expected to be completed by July 2027. (Roundtable Weekly, Sept. 11)
  • DOE’s Office of Critical Minerals and Energy Innovation (CMEI) will oversee the program, including its information technology portfolio, Portfolio Manager, and related datasets. (Roundtable Weekly, March 6 | Roundtable Weekly, Sept. 11)

Why It Matters

  • ENERGY STAR has helped American families and businesses save more than $500 billion in energy costs since 1992. The coalition emphasized that the voluntary public-private partnership supports energy affordability, competitiveness, and broader national energy objectives. (Coalition Letter, Oct. 29)
  • RER and its coalition partners have consistently advocated for preserving ENERGY STAR as a voluntary federal program, supporting DOE’s new leadership role and urging Congress to maintain adequate funding and oversight. (Roundtable Weekly, April 17 | Roundtable Weekly, April 3)

RER and our coalition partners will rally congressional appropriators to include ENERGY STAR funding in FY’27 spending legislation considered during the upcoming lame duck session.

Energy Policy Update: Permitting Reform, Data Center Growth and Tax Proposals

A bipartisan group of former senior administration officials is urging Congress to advance permitting reform legislation, citing growing energy demand, infrastructure delays, and threats to U.S. economic competitiveness. The push comes as new research highlights the economic impact of data center development and Senate Democrats introduce proposals to reshape federal energy and data center tax incentives. (The Hill | Axios, Oct. 21)

Permitting Reform

  • Nineteen former economic and national security officials from five presidential administrations urged congressional leaders to pass bipartisan permitting reform legislation, warning that lengthy approval processes are hindering infrastructure development, economic growth, and national security. (The Hill, Oct. 21)
  • Signatories included former Treasury Secretaries Janet Yellen, Steven Mnuchin, Timothy Geithner, Henry Paulson Jr. and Robert Rubin, along with former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and seven former chairs of the Council of Economic Advisers.
  • The officials endorsed the bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, introduced Sept. 30 by Sens. Shelley Moore Capito (R-WV), Mike Lee (R-UT), Martin Heinrich (D-NM) and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), which would reform federal environmental review and permitting processes. (Roundtable Weekly, Oct. 2)
  • The officials warned that permitting delays are particularly concerning as artificial intelligence and data center development drive electricity demand. Faster infrastructure approvals could expand electricity supply, reduce reliance on costly on-site generation and help lower consumer energy costs.

RER Advocacy

  • The Real Estate Roundtable (RER) has consistently supported bipartisan permitting reform to strengthen grid reliability, lower energy costs, and accelerate infrastructure investment.
  • In a December 2025 letter to congressional leadership, RER urged passage of the bipartisan SPEED Act (H.R. 4776), emphasizing that duplicative federal reviews delay the delivery of affordable, reliable electricity to homes and commercial buildings. (RER Letter, Dec. 8 | Roundtable Weekly, Dec. 12)

Data Center Economic Impact

  • A new U.S. Chamber of Commerce study found that data centers generate substantial economic activity, employment, and local tax revenue, underscoring their role in supporting communities and infrastructure investment. (U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Oct. 15)
  • By the Numbers: According to the Chamber’s analysis, economic impacts generated by a typical 50-megawatt data center include:
  • 5,200 jobs annually supported statewide during a two-year construction phase, generating approximately $680 million in economic activity.
  • $114 million in local tax revenue projected over five years in Prince William County, Virginia, with similar benefits estimated for communities in Texas, Georgia, and Ohio.
  • The findings come as lawmakers debate how to accommodate growing data center electricity demand while protecting consumers from higher infrastructure costs.
  • RER has also urged the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) to develop clear, workable grid reliability standards that reflect the distinct responsibilities of data center owners, operators, and tenants. (Roundtable Weekly, Sept. 18)
  • Meanwhile, congressional Democrats plan to ramp up oversight of the Trump Administration’s efforts to avoid federal environmental standards for data centers if they take control of the House and/or Senate after the midterms. (PoliticoPro, Oct. 22)

Data Center Tax Proposals

Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR)
  • Senate Finance Committee Ranking Member Ron Wyden (D-OR) released draft legislation Friday that would impose an excise tax on data center operators and eliminate several federal tax incentives for data center investment, including bonus depreciation, Opportunity Zone benefits and research and development tax credits. (Press Release | Senate Finance Committee Summary | Draft Legislation, Oct. 23)
  • The proposal builds on Wyden’s August white paper, which also called for restrictions on certain data center investments through real estate investment trusts (REITs). (Roundtable Weekly, Aug. 7)
  • The proposed changes would create tax penalties specifically targeting data centers by excluding them from longstanding incentives available to other capital investments. (Roundtable Weekly, Aug. 7)

Clean Energy Tax Incentives

  • Sen. Wyden (D-OR) also outlined plans to restore wind and solar tax credits and expand the Inflation Reduction Act’s Direct Pay Program if Democrats regain control of the Senate. (Politico, Oct. 22)
  • A new Senate Finance Committee Democratic staff report found that nearly $2.5 billion in direct payments went to tax-exempt entities during the program’s first two years, supporting renewable energy and other clean energy investments. (Sen. Wyden Press Release, Oct. 22)

The November elections will shape prospects for permitting reform, data center regulation and federal energy tax policy, with several proposals potentially returning to the agenda during the lame-duck session or the next Congress.

Affordability, Ratepayer Protections Drive Data Center Policies on Capitol Hill

Congress and federal regulators focused this week on how to meet rapidly growing electricity demand from data centers and AI while protecting consumers, strengthening grid reliability, and accelerating new energy infrastructure.

State of Play

  • All five Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) commissioners testified Wednesday before the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, where lawmakers from both parties focused heavily on ensuring that the costs of serving new data centers and other large loads are not shifted to existing ratepayers. (E&E News, July 23 | Bloomberg Government, July 22)
  • “FERC now sits at the center of some of the most important questions facing our country: reliable electricity, affordable energy, data centers, manufacturing, national security,” said committee chair Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT). “Every one of these issues, in its own way, now runs directly through FERC.” (PoliticoPro, July 22)
  • Commissioners and senators discussed broader strategies to expand grid capacity, including grid-enhancing technologies that can increase the capacity of existing transmission infrastructure, and permitting reform. (Daily Energy Insider, July 22 | New York Times, July 23)
  • FERC is also moving to address the reliability risks associated with large computational loads, directing the North American Electric Reliability Corp. (NERC) to finalize new reliability standards and registration requirements for certain computational loads by the end of 2026. (Roundtable Weekly, July 17)

Data Center Legislation

  • On Tuesday, the House Energy and Commerce Committee unanimously approved the bipartisan Ratepayer Protection Act (H.R. 9340) by a 52-0 vote. The bill would require state utility regulators to consider standards to ensure data centers cover the incremental costs of the energy infrastructure needed to serve them, rather than shifting those costs to other customers. (Energy& Commerce Committee Press Release, July 21)
  • The framework includes the Data Center Tax Accountability and Disclosure Act, which would require large AI data centers to disclose information about energy and water use, emissions, backup generation, and other operational impacts, while conditioning federal bonus depreciation on meeting “LEED Gold” rating standards. (Sen. Warner Press Release, July 21)
  • State policymakers are also reassessing data center development and tax incentives. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul recently imposed a one-year moratorium on new large-scale data centers and said she will pursue legislation to eliminate certain tax incentives for the facilities. (Fortune, July 14 | PoliticoPro, July 20)
  • Arizona has paused new data center sales tax incentives for three years, while leaders in other states are also examining changes to incentive structures. (Fortune, July 14 | PoliticoPro, July 20)

AI and the Regulatory Process

  • The IRS is considering whether AI could help analyze comments while still meeting Administrative Procedure Act requirements, though GAO found the agency does not currently have such tools. (Politico, July 24)
  • For The Real Estate Roundtable (RER), which regularly submits substantive comments to Treasury, the IRS, and other agencies, the potential use of AI in regulatory review could significantly change how stakeholder input is processed and underscores the importance of ensuring meaningful consideration of technical advocacy.

Permitting Push

  • As Senate negotiators work toward a broader permitting reform deal, House Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Brett Guthrie (R-KY) moved to stake out House priorities by releasing a discussion draft of the Permitting Our Way to an Energy Resurgence (POWER) Act, a 19-bill package aimed at accelerating pipelines, power generation, transmission, and industrial projects. (E&E News | E&C Press Release | Bill Text, July 22)

With energy demand surging, real estate is an important partner in supporting energy investment, increasing efficiency, and delivering energy savings across the economy. The Real Estate Roundtable (RER) and its Sustainability Policy Advisory Committee (SPAC) continue to monitor federal and state actions affecting grid capacity, energy costs, infrastructure permitting, and data center development.

Solar Credit “Safe Harbor” Restored; Court Cites RER Comments

A Washington, D.C. federal court this week fully restored the long-standing “5% Safe Harbor” as a valid method for solar projects to establish the key “beginning of construction” date—before certain energy tax credits start phasing out under the GOP’s tax law passed last summer. (Reuters, June 8 | Holland & Knight, June 8)

Why It Matters

  • The June 6 court decision restores a key tax credit pathway that real estate owners, developers, and investors have relied on for more than a decade to plan rooftop solar and other clean energy investments.
  • The court’s opinion cited comments submitted by The Real Estate Roundtable (RER) and coalition partners urging the IRS to preserve the long-standing, clear-cut rule to establish “beginning-of-construction” based on expenditure of 5% of project costs. (Letter, Aug. 8 | Roundtable Weekly, Sept. 5, 2025)
  • Under the ruling, projects that spend 5% of project costs by July 4, 2026, have a longer time period to preserve tax credit eligibility under the beginning-of-construction deadline set by the One Big Beautiful Bill (OB3) Act. (McGuire Woods, June 8)

RER Advocacy

  • RER, Nareit, NAIOP, and ICSC submitted a joint letter to Treasury in August 2025, urging the IRS to continue allowing taxpayers to rely on both the 5% Safe Harbor and the Physical Work Test to show “beginning of construction.” (Letter, Aug. 8 | RW, Sept. 5, 2025)
  • The court cited the RER coalition letter, explaining that businesses have relied on the 5% cost test as a valid method for tax credit eligibility  “for more than twelve years.” (Memorandum Opinion, June 6)
  • The court also cited the letter in recognizing the coalition’s concerns to avoid “stranding capital already invested” in rooftop solar and similar projects that relied upon the well-established safe harbor. (Memorandum Opinion, June 6)

The Ruling

  • The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia found that the IRS acted arbitrarily and capriciously under the Administrative Procedure Act when it eliminated the 5% Safe Harbor for most wind and solar facilities. (Memorandum Opinion, June 6)
  • Most commercial building rooftop projects met the small-scale threshold—but this week’s court decision reinstates the cost-based safe harbor for large-scale installations as well. (JD Supra, June 9 | Nixon Peabody, June 10)
  • The ruling does not change the OB3 Act’s underlying “beginning of construction” deadlines. Projects that start construction by this coming July 4 must be “placed in service” by the end of 2030. Projects that start construction after this coming July 4 must be “placed in service” by the end of 2027. (RER Fact Sheet, Aug. 27)

The IRS could issue revised guidance or appeal the court’s ruling. In the meantime, the decision restores the 5% Safe Harbor as a planning tool for clean energy projects seeking to meet the July 4 “beginning-of-construction” deadline.

Federal Oversight of Data Centers Ramps Up

The North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) issued its highest-level grid alert this week, warning that data centers, crypto mining operations, and other large “computational loads” are creating new reliability risks as electricity demand accelerates across the country.  (NERC, May 4)

Why It Matters

  • NERC is the international regulatory “grid watchdog” that ensures reliability and security of North America’s bulk electricity system.
  • NERC’s Level 3 Essential Action Alert directs grid operators, transmission planners, and utilities to address risks from large loads that can unexpectedly disconnect from the grid or create significant power swings within seconds. (NERC, May 4)
  • The alert follows incidents involving data centers across the East Coast and Texas, where large loads unexpectedly dropped off the grid, raising concerns about frequency, voltage, and overall power system reliability. (Utility Dive, May 5)
  • A Union of Concerned Scientists representative called the alert a “big deal,” noting it is only the third Level 3 alert in NERC’s history. (PoliticoPro, May 4)
  • The alert signals a broader shift toward future data center regulations that could require such large power users to register with NERC, just as entities that own and operate the electric grid must currently do. (PoliticoPro, May 4). Entities that register with NERC must comply with its grid reliability standards.
  • NERC also released voluntary risk-mitigation guidelines while it develops formal reliability standards for data centers and other large loads. (E&E News May 4)
  • Meanwhile, the alert outlines “essential actions” for current NERC registrants, such as stronger modeling of computational loads, more frequent stability studies, and installation of fault-recording equipment to better understand how data centers behave during grid disturbances. Grid planners are asked to respond by Aug. 3. (NERC, May 4)
  • Separately, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) is drafting a proposal that could provide more federal oversight on how large data centers must connect to the power grid. (Latitude Media | E&E News, May 4)

Data Centers & Electricity Demand Growth

  • NERC’s warning comes as data centers face growing scrutiny over their energy use, infrastructure impacts, and effects on electricity costs. (NYT, April 27)
  • Eleven states have proposed legislation since late 2025 to restrict or ban data center development, while Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) have introduced legislation to pause new data center construction nationwide. (Axios, April 5)
  • At a House Energy subcommittee hearing last week, witnesses argued that large-load customers such as data centers should cover the full incremental costs of the generation, transmission, and distribution upgrades needed to serve them. (Politico | Hearing, April 30)
  • Separately, the U.S. Green Building Council (USBGC) and eight partner organizations launched the Greening AI Data Centers Coalition to coordinate on non-governmental sustainability standards for AI data centers, including performance criteria for energy, carbon, water, waste, biodiversity, and community impact. (USGBC, April 22)
  • Data centers are not the only source of rising power demand, but they are accelerating a broader challenge: the nation needs more generation, more transmission, faster permitting, and better grid planning to support economic growth, housing development, and U.S. technological leadership. (NYT, April 27)

Electricity Costs & Infrastructure

  • The Chamber noted that rising demand alone does not determine electricity costs. States with major data center hubs, including Virginia, Texas, and North Carolina, continue to have electricity rates below the national average, underscoring the importance of generation mix, infrastructure capacity, and state-level policy decisions. (Chamber of Commerce, May 5)
  • Infrastructure bottlenecks are adding to the challenge. Wood Mackenzie estimates the U.S. electrical equipment market tied to data centers could more than triple from $20 billion to $65 billion by 2030, while shortages of transformers and other equipment have stretched lead times to 18 to 36 months and pushed prices up as much as 20 percent. (Wood Mackenzie, April 28)

Roundtable View

  • The Real Estate Roundtable (RER) has consistently emphasized that grid reliability is essential to expanding the nation’s housing supply, spurring new real estate development, supporting economic growth, and advancing U.S. technological leadership.
  • RER supports a national “all of the above” energy strategy that invests in building efficiency, grid modernization, faster permitting, and innovation across all energy sources. (RER’s Spring Policy Priorities-Energy)

Policymakers should continue advancing permitting reforms to accelerate construction of transmission lines, pipelines, and generation plants—helping reduce delays, expand

RER and Coalition Partners Call on Congress to Ensure Continued ENERGY STAR Funding

As focus on Capitol Hill shifted to appropriations talks this week, The Real Estate Roundtable (RER) and a broad coalition of organizations representing the real estate, consumer products, manufacturing, and retail sectors sent a letter urging congressional leaders to ensure that the ENERGY STAR program remains amply funded in the 2027 fiscal year (FY’27), starting Oct. 1.

Coalition Advocacy

  • On Tuesday, the multi-industry coalition requested that House and Senate appropriators include explicit funding for ENERGY STAR in the FY’27 spending bill, in line with FY’26 funding levels. (Letter, April 14)
  • The letter also encouraged lawmakers to include strong congressional oversight measures in the legislation, as lead agency responsibilities for the program shift from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to the Department of Energy (DOE). (Letter, April 14)
  • In the letter, the coalition recommended that legislators consolidate past funding for ENERGY STAR expressly given to the EPA, plus amounts used by DOE historically to run its portion of the program. (Letter, April 14)
  • Congress provided approximately $33 million for ENERGY STAR to EPA in the FY’26 appropriations bill (H.R. 6938), signed into law on Jan. 23, preserving the program through Sept. 30 following earlier reports that it could be privatized or defunded. (Roundtable Weekly, April 3)
  • Though President Trump’s FY’27 budget request, released this month, does not specifically mention ENERGY STAR—as was the case last year—the White House has proposed cutting DOE and EPA’s overall budgets by 11 percent and 52 percent, respectively. (Budget of the U.S. Government, April 3)

DOE Budget Hearings

  • This week, DOE Secretary Chris Wright appeared before the House Committee on Energy and Commerce (E&C) and a subcommittee of the House Committee on Appropriations to discuss the agency’s FY’27 budget request. 
  • Though most of Sec. Wright’s testimony did not focus on ENERGY STAR, Rep. Paul Tonko (D-NY) raised the topic during Thursday’s E&C hearing. (Watch Hearing)
  • Rep. Tonko noted the importance of ENERGY STAR and pointed out that ENERGY STAR has historically required approximately $35 million in annual funding. (Watch Hearing)
  • When asked if DOE would be seeking that funding as part of its budget request, and if he could provide assurance that DOE is already working to put the people and resources in place to transition and manage the program, Sec. Wright said he would follow up on the details. (Watch Hearing)
  • Still, Sec. Wright added that he is “all for” voluntary energy efficiency ratings on appliances as well as data and transparency. (Watch Hearing)
  • The bulk of the two hearings this week focused on a range of other topics, including rising energy prices, permitting reform, and nuclear power. (Politico E&E News, April 16)

Roundtable View

  • In March, RER and coalition partners sent a letter expressing support for DOE assuming its new role as lead federal agency for ENERGY STAR. (Roundtable Weekly, April 3)
  • Additionally, the March letter underscored that DOE is well-positioned to lead a modernized program that continues to provide consumers and businesses with access to efficient products and buildings that uphold the performance they have come to expect from the ENERGY STAR brand. (Roundtable Weekly, April 3)
  • RER and coalition partners have long made the business case for ENERGY STAR and emphasized its status as a federal program required by law—meaning that it cannot be privatized or operated outside the U.S. government by agency decree. (Roundtable Weekly, April 3 | Roundtable Weekly, March 6) 
  • As Tuesday’s coalition letter highlighted, “Since 1992, ENERGY STAR and its partners have helped American families and businesses save more than $500 billion in energy costs.” (Letter, April 14)
  • By driving cost savings through energy efficiency, the program contributes to reducing energy waste and freeing up capacity on the electricity grid, in alignment with President Trump’s goal to “unleash America’s energy dominance.” (RER Policy Priorities Document)

Next week, Sec. Wright is scheduled to appear before Senate appropriators to discuss DOE’s budget request. RER will continue to track developments related to ENERGY STAR funding and support the continuation of the program and its smooth transition to DOE.

Roundtable and Coalition Support ENERGY STAR Transition to the Department of Energy

The Real Estate Roundtable (RER) joined a broad coalition of organizations representing the consumer products, manufacturing, real estate, and retail sectors this week to support the Department of Energy’s (DOE) new role as lead federal agency for ENERGY STAR, following the recent Memorandum of Agreement with the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). (RER News Release, March 31 | Memorandum of Agreement, March 3)

ENERGY STAR Coalition Letter

  • In a coalition letter sent this week to DOE, the groups said they look forward to collaborating with the agency to ensure an effective transition that maintains and evolves the voluntary ENERGY STAR public-private partnership. (Letter, March 30 | PoliticoPro, March 31)
  • The coalition emphasized that DOE is well-positioned to lead a modernized ENERGY STAR program that continues to provide consumers and businesses with access to efficient products and buildings with the performance they have come to expect from the ENERGY STAR brand.
  • The letter also reaffirmed strong support for keeping ENERGY STAR within the federal government. (Letter, March 30)
  • “Our longstanding partnership with the federal government’s ENERGY STAR program remains a top priority as DOE assumes the lead implementation role,” said RER’s President & CEO Jeffrey D. DeBoer. “DOE has the data, talent, lab research, and other resources to run all facets of ENERGY STAR efficiently and effectively. Down the years, ENERGY STAR for buildings has saved families and businesses hundreds of billions of dollars in energy costs, and helps create greater capacity on the grid to boost economic growth. We will continue to partner in the evolution of ENERGY STAR to support the economic growth in our buildings, plants, and consumer products.” (RER News Release, March 31)
  • Congress provided approximately $33 million for ENERGY STAR to EPA in the FY’26 appropriations bill (H.R. 6938), signed into law on Jan. 23, preserving the program through Sept. 30 following earlier reports that it could be privatized or defunded. (Roundtable Weekly, Jan. 9 | Utility Dive, March 10) 
  • Additionally, the letter noted that the program has helped save families and businesses more than $500 billion in energy costs since 1992. (Letter, March 30)

Roundtable View

Tony Malkin (Chairman and CEO, Empire State Realty Trust, Inc.), chair of The Roundtable’s Sustainability Policy Advisory (SPAC) Committee.
RER’s Sustainability Policy Advisory Committee (SPAC) Chair Anthony E. Malkin (Chairman and CEO, Empire State Realty Trust, Inc.)
  • RER has long made the business case for ENERGY STAR and, with coalition partners, emphasized that it is a federal program required by law—not one that can be privatized or operated outside the U.S. government by agency decree. (Roundtable Weekly, Mar. 6)
  • Last year, RER joined dozens of industry groups in a letter to Congress to support the ENERGY STAR. The multi-industry letter cited federal statutes that compel ENERGY STAR to be a program run by federal agencies, with DOE and EPA authorized to assign program responsibilities between themselves. (Roundtable Weekly, Jun. 6, 2025). 
  • “DOE has always been a key part of the ENERGY STAR ecosystem and is ideally suited to assume the role as the program’s primary steward and ensure its vitality and progress forward,” said RER’s Sustainability Policy Advisory Committee (SPAC) Chair Anthony E. Malkin (Chairman and CEO, Empire State Realty Trust, Inc.).
  • “ENERGY STAR has long enhanced the profitability of buildings and established a voluntary reporting structure for real estate assets. It helps our industry attract investors from all over the world to the United States. ENERGY STAR works better than any other building energy ‘label’ on the market because it is grounded in quantifiable metrics and deploys standard software geared to save money on utility bills and avoid wasted energy,” added Malkin.
  • Malkin continued, “Our industry coalition with leading organizations in the real estate, manufacturing, consumer tech, and retail sectors will continue to advocate to Congress and the Executive branch the critical role ENERGY STAR plays to advance America’s energy dominance and global competitiveness.”

RER will continue working with policymakers and aligned stakeholders to help ensure a smooth and productive transition for ENERGY STAR.

DOE Assumes Lead Responsibilities for ENERGY STAR

A federal agency Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) signed this week provides that the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) will assume lead responsibilities to implement the ENERGY STAR program as oversight of the effective, popular, and voluntary public-private partnership shifts from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). (E&E News, March 5)

ENERGY STAR Transition

  • DOE and EPA signed the MOA for an “orderly” transition of ENERGY STAR activities including oversight of partnership agreements, trademarks, and related IT systems and databases. (Memorandum, March 2)
  • The MOA explains that a 90-day plan will provide details regarding the agencies’ transition.
  • The MOA further explains that transition activities will be initially funded by each agency using their own funds appropriated by Congress. Federal law authorizes DOE and EPA to transfer funds “as the transition progresses.”
  • Congress provided approximately $33 million for ENERGY STAR to EPA in the FY’26 appropriations bill (H.R. 6938), signed into law on Jan. 23. This law maintains funding through Sept. 30 and preserves ENERGY STAR following prior Trump administration reports to privatize the program – or de-fund it altogether. (Roundtable Weekly, Jan. 9) 

Why It Matters

  • The Real Estate Roundtable’s (RER) advocacy, in collaboration with coalition partners in the real estate, manufacturing, and consumer products sectors, has long emphasized that ENERGY STAR is a federal program required by federal law. It cannot be privatized or run outside of the U.S. government by agency decree. (Roundtable Weekly, May 9, 2025)
  • For example, RER joined dozens of industry groups last year in a letter to Congress to “strongly support continuation of the non-regulatory and non-partisan ENERGY STAR program within the federal government.” (Roundtable Weekly, June 6). The multi-industry letter cites federal statutes that compel ENERGY STAR to be a program run by federal agencies—with DOE and EPA authorized to assign program responsibilities between themselves, as indicated by this week’s Memorandum of Agreement.

RER View

Tony Malkin (Chairman and CEO, Empire State Realty Trust, Inc.), chair of The Roundtable’s Sustainability Policy Advisory (SPAC) Committee.
Tony Malkin (Chairman and CEO, Empire State Realty Trust, Inc.)
  • RER has long urged the “business case” to support the ENERGY STAR program.
  • “We look forward to continuing our longstanding partnership with the federal government’s ENERGY STAR program as DOE assumes the lead implementation role,” said RER’s President & CEO Jeffrey D. DeBoer. “DOE has the data, talent, lab research, and other resources to run all facets of ENERGY STAR efficiently and effectively. Down the years, ENERGY STAR for buildings has saved families and businesses hundreds of billions of dollars in energy costs, and helps create greater capacity on the grid to boost economic growth. We are ready to roll-up-our-sleeves to evolve ENERGY STAR to support a new generation of cutting-edge buildings, plants, and consumer products.”
  • “DOE has long been a key part of the ENERGY STAR ecosystem and is ideally suited to assume the role as the program’s primary steward,” said RER’s Sustainability Policy Advisory Committee (SPAC) Chair, Anthony E. Malkin (Chairman and CEO, Empire State Realty Trust, Inc.). “ENERGY STAR enhances profitability of buildings and establishes a voluntary reporting structure for real estate assets. It helps our industry attract investors from all over the world to the United States. ENERGY STAR works better than any other building energy ‘label’ on the market because it is grounded in quantifiable metrics and deploys standard software geared to save money on utility bills and avoid wasted energy.”
  • Malkin continued, “Real estate’s coalition with the manufacturing sector will continue to impress upon Congress and the Trump administration the critical role ENERGY STAR plays to advance America’s energy dominance and global competitiveness.”

In the coming months, RER will partner with DOE, EPA, and aligned stakeholders to accomplish a seamless and productive transition of the ENERGY STAR program.